Originality and copyright

Copying others’ art – deliberate or serendipity?

Nov 6th, 2007 | By Aisling | Category: Originality and copyright

We’re all inspired by outside sources. I see nothing wrong with seeing, say, Dave McKean using cheesecloth for texture in his art, and realizing that it’s a great idea… an idea that I intend to use in my own art, in my own way.
Is that “copying”? I’m not sure. Depends upon your definition, I suppose.
But, [...]



Trademarks, original ideas, and copycats

Jun 23rd, 2007 | By Aisling | Category: Originality and copyright

Copying is a regular topic of discussion among artists. Recently, someone suggested copyright and trademarks as ways to protect clever product or workshop names that we use, and so on.
I can’t give you legal advice. I’m not a lawyer. But, here are a [...]



Copyright and the ‘three stroke’ rule

Jun 1st, 2007 | By Aisling | Category: Originality and copyright

The “three stroke” rule suggests that you can copy anyone’s art as long as at least three brush strokes are different.
This is NOT a law. In fact, even within clear copyright law, every legal case will return a different decision.
My background in copyright law
I’m not a lawyer, so this is opinion and based [...]



When a student copies

Jun 23rd, 2006 | By Aisling | Category: Originality and copyright, Teaching

In the days of the Old Masters, apprentices and students would copy their masters’ works over & over again, until they could mimic the technique perfectly. Then, they’d develop their own styles.
When a student (or someone who’s learning a new technique) copies my art exactly–or very closely–I like to think of them in that context. [...]



Copying and coincidence in art

May 10th, 2006 | By Aisling | Category: Originality and copyright

Many artists–especially new and/or tired ones–talk about being “copied” by others. Sometimes, it’s not clear who is doing the copying, if anyone is. And, artists–even established ones–are often influenced by the same things as others, and develop startlingly similar ideas as a result.
RICE’S MILAGROS DOLLS
For example, awhile ago I [...]



Copyright and art

Jan 17th, 2006 | By Aisling | Category: Originality and copyright

Someone asked me about copyright law, the Sargent images that I’m using in my Cafe Press collages, and if it’s okay to use more modern images in collages that will be reproduced by Cafe Press.
I’m not an attorney, so this is my personal opinion.In general–works created before 1923 are in the [...]



Art, energy and originality

Mar 1st, 2005 | By Aisling | Category: Originality and copyright

This morning, I was looking for a quote by Stuart Wilde, in his slightly-renegade book, “The Trick to Money is Having Some.”
Here’s a section that I particularly like, about making money:
(He calls the mundane/average world, “tick-tock,” since people live by the clock in that world, and it can be metronome dull.)
In tick-tock people see the [...]